Comments on: Sachar Committee Report-Diagnosis of Muslims in India http://indianmuslims.in/sachar-committee-report-diagnosis-of-muslims-in-india/ A Window Into The Indian Muslim Life Sat, 03 Jul 2010 11:20:27 -0700 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.0 By: Mehman http://indianmuslims.in/sachar-committee-report-diagnosis-of-muslims-in-india/comment-page-1/#comment-34980 Mehman Thu, 15 Nov 2007 07:27:12 +0000 http://indianmuslims.in/sachar-committee-report-diagnosis-of-muslims-in-india/#comment-34980 A very intersting thing a friend of mine read me out of the Asian Age one day is that the number of different categories of educated personnel in India are more compared to those Pakistan's. Keeping in mind the progress Pakistan has attained in the past 60 odd years and their comparision viz a viz India. A thought flashes in my mind, that is if this is the case, I feel instead of finding faults only from within, we need to give a serious thought to the fact that there is a clear discrimination. The so called merit is of no consequence if we want a group 'C' and 'D' employee. This is well supported with the stats of the IAS/IPS/AFS cadre, where the percentage of Muslims was higher. We find it hard to get one become a constable, whereas we have DGPs and Ambassadors (IFS). We need to have a semblance of being true to the spirit of merit and mind it, if we have a constable in a company of 10 policemen, there wont be unproved firing we have hundreds of examples. Conversely, can we ask for tax exemptions if we pay zakat etc as is given to HUF? We need to demand as the definition and practice of democracy depends of people. Unfortunately here, the practice is going the fascist way. A very intersting thing a friend of mine read me out of the Asian Age one day is that the number of different categories of educated personnel in India are more compared to those Pakistan’s. Keeping in mind the progress Pakistan has attained in the past 60 odd years and their comparision viz a viz India. A thought flashes in my mind, that is if this is the case, I feel instead of finding faults only from within, we need to give a serious thought to the fact that there is a clear discrimination. The so called merit is of no consequence if we want a group ‘C’ and ‘D’ employee. This is well supported with the stats of the IAS/IPS/AFS cadre, where the percentage of Muslims was higher. We find it hard to get one become a constable, whereas we have DGPs and Ambassadors (IFS). We need to have a semblance of being true to the spirit of merit and mind it, if we have a constable in a company of 10 policemen, there wont be unproved firing we have hundreds of examples. Conversely, can we ask for tax exemptions if we pay zakat etc as is given to HUF? We need to demand as the definition and practice of democracy depends of people. Unfortunately here, the practice is going the fascist way.

]]> By: Razaul Hassan http://indianmuslims.in/sachar-committee-report-diagnosis-of-muslims-in-india/comment-page-1/#comment-34936 Razaul Hassan Tue, 13 Nov 2007 04:28:47 +0000 http://indianmuslims.in/sachar-committee-report-diagnosis-of-muslims-in-india/#comment-34936 I completely agree with this idea of spreading education among our Muslim Brother and Sisters at the grass root.I am from Delhi and I want to impart education among our community.I would love to work it,given a chance. razaul2_2000@yahoo.com I completely agree with this idea of spreading education among our Muslim Brother and Sisters at the grass root.I am from Delhi and I want to impart education among our community.I would love to work it,given a chance.

razaul2_2000@yahoo.com

]]> By: Dr. Rubina Khan http://indianmuslims.in/sachar-committee-report-diagnosis-of-muslims-in-india/comment-page-1/#comment-27340 Dr. Rubina Khan Tue, 11 Sep 2007 16:07:53 +0000 http://indianmuslims.in/sachar-committee-report-diagnosis-of-muslims-in-india/#comment-27340 Excellent thoughts!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Keep up the good work. Excellent thoughts!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Keep up the good work.

]]> By: Mohammed Imtiaz http://indianmuslims.in/sachar-committee-report-diagnosis-of-muslims-in-india/comment-page-1/#comment-9684 Mohammed Imtiaz Sat, 21 Apr 2007 12:41:34 +0000 http://indianmuslims.in/sachar-committee-report-diagnosis-of-muslims-in-india/#comment-9684 Dear Mr.K.M Raziuddin, Salam Aleykum,wa rahamtullahi,wa barakatuhu, It is true that because of low literacy rate Muslims are lagging behind in all aspects, your suggestion is very much appreciatable and adoptable, as you said that the youth has to come forward. Start tutorials, coaching classes in localities. Teach the underprivileged. And to look that Every Muslim child should go to school,. Inshallah, Then definitely community would surge ahead. In my opinion besides literacy we must try to bring political awareness in the community so that they can understand the political drama about our minority status, and why we are not well placed in administration or politics? We have started an organization in Guntur Andhrapradesh to promote similar programmes and to monitor the distribution of the benefits to the Muslim minorities from the govt. Inshallah with all our brothers support we will continue. Allah Hafiz, Imtiaz.Mohammed Dear Mr.K.M Raziuddin,
Salam Aleykum,wa rahamtullahi,wa barakatuhu,

It is true that because of low literacy rate Muslims are lagging behind in all aspects, your suggestion is very much appreciatable and adoptable, as you said that the youth has to come forward. Start tutorials, coaching classes in localities. Teach the underprivileged. And to look that Every Muslim child should go to school,. Inshallah, Then definitely community would surge ahead.
In my opinion besides literacy we must try to bring political awareness in the community so that they can understand the political drama about our minority status, and why we are not well placed in administration or politics?
We have started an organization in Guntur Andhrapradesh to promote similar programmes and to monitor the distribution of the benefits to the Muslim minorities from the govt. Inshallah with all our brothers support we will continue.

Allah Hafiz,
Imtiaz.Mohammed

]]>