Karkare
Keeping, apart statements given by the minority’s minister.
BRAVE OFFICER WHO LOST LIFE’S PROTECTING OUR LIFE’S
While I strongly condemn this act, of Terror in Mumbai. I at the same time would remember the true hero of our forces Late Mr. Hemant Karkare and the many decorated upright officers of our police force and NSG.
-
Mrs. Karkare you are wife of a great SOUL a great leader, a great protector of law, a great Indian, a great son of our great country India, India will never be able to pay back what he has given to our nation
-
This goes to all others who lost there lives from our forces. India and its police and armed forces will take the path of late Mr. Karkare and there will be thousands more like him who will be inspired and would like to be Hemant Karkares, and Unnikrishnans…
-
MR. HEMANT KARKARE WE SALUTE YOUR BRAVENESS. You are our hero and a martyr.
-
But humble concern which we all have in our minds is , the world would like to know in the circumstances they reached on the day of action at the location of terror, were they martyrs equipped enough and secured enough and covered enough to face the terrorist.
THE WORLD WOULD LIKE TO KNOW ABOUT THEM, FOR SURE.
-
Was the security and the protection provided to them, on the day they lost their life’s bravely fighting and protecting our life’s, was sufficient to the stature and the threat they were to face in handling the terror attack of the intensity we witnessed.
-
These officers were heading very delicate investigation of terror acts involving very sensitive issues, where in many innocent people lost lives.
CAN WE EVER FORGIVE OURSELVES IF WE AS A NATON FAILED…?
-
To provide them proper protective cover, gadgets, shields, and arms and Ammunition to match the enemy they were asked to fight with?
-
I appeal to all, please raise your voice to force the authorities and people in power to provide enough infrastructure support and modernise the police to encourage more people to join the police and Armey and NSG as they too have families waiting for them when they risk life’s fighting and protecting us.
-
Please think…this is main issue. (To know how safe the live jacket of this officer was. Please read the interview of Mr. Karan
Thapar with Mr. Kapil Sibal Union Minister it is discussed in detail on cnnibn). The live jackets used by our martyrs were the ones that are used in riots. which by no standards can protect the forces exposed to bullet shots from AK56 weapons, and other sophisticated weapons the terrorist used. Pl. pause and thinks…
NATION IS UNITED IN THIS HOUR, PAIN.
-
Late Hemant Karkare Sir it is painful to know you are not with us any more.
-
God will punish those who killed you and all the other innocent people in Mumbai terror attack with you.
-
Nation with all thrust and unity punish the killers of Mumbai terror attacks, were ever they are.
-
The nation is united and is determined to do so. It is the question of Indian Pride.
-
We should further show wisdom in our actions and how we express our feelings.
Mr Hemant Karkare has performed an act of heroism which has stirred sentiments in a way that no celluloid hero can. He has been selflessness and bravery personified.
The best way in which we can honor his memory is to see that the police force has the best training, weapons and support. That is something which would have truly made him happy.
And let us ensure that NOBODY interferes with the functioning of our policemen. Train and arm them well – they are better in courage and intelligence than any other force in the world.
Hindutva political parties and hindutva media purposely mis-quoted the statement of Antulay !
India is democratic country and Antulay have right to ask saperate enquiry in Killing of Hemant Karkare, because India has lost an Important and brave office/person, who was investigating the past terror attacks, fearlessly, which leads to terror links even inside India. Moreover, if you are not investigate the matter than you are not supporting the officer/persons who want to work like Mr. karkare.
I think People who are against Antulay enquiry demand are against defeating terrorism in India!
Well Well Untrusted Indian Muslim Yeah defintly he has a right to speak in democrazy,but it wasn’t the right time he let the muslims and country down
If had any problem or any DOubt
1.he was the Union Minister he could have gone to Sonai OR Prime Minister,
2.You Belive it or not It has given good amount oppurnity to bash INDIA in Pakistan Media.
3.he belongs to party which he is in power in center as well as in State
4.He is talking about who given the instruction to ATS FYI Mumbai Commisioner is Muslim
He just had played a politics of division.
@Sarfaraz,
What’s wrong with timings, you want to fight with terror or you want to play a political game over the people killed in all the terror attacks ?
1. Why he need to go to sonia or PM ? than what for parliament is made for ?
2. Why we need to afraid with Pak Media, on one hand you are saying the involvement of Pakistan in terror attacks on the other hands you are having fear of pakistan media, it mean you are not sure about the involvement of Pakisatn ?
3. If he is in the party who are in power in state and centre, so he has to safe the party or the people ?
4. Mumbai Commissioner is muslims, for the sake of Muslims commissioner Antulay need to save commissioner or the truth ?
Now people is having doubts, who is playing the politics with the people killed in terror attacks ?
Untrusted Indian Muslims,
Antulay is not helping any people by what he is doing. He is simply helping himself and to an extent may be congress.
Whatever are the details of what he said, he knew one thing for sure that is this mumbai terror attacks will become a hindu vs muslim issue instead of being treated as what they actually are( which he too may agree , but of no use), anti-India terrorist acts. The other thing he certainly knew was, he had other avenues of expressing his concerns and getting them addressed. But that is not his intention. his calculations were different. The more BJP targets him the more of a hero he becomes among people like you. Then he is indespensible for congress, which of course has proven track record of compromising for such votes. Already you can see how congress treats him and how he becomes happy when BJP hurls accusations at him.This is not the way a mature, concerned polititian with a sense of purpose of getting justice for someone behaves. His behaviour is too cheap. Unfortunately congress has no leaders,no ideology and no firmness in implementing policies. Anyone can do anything and get away.
Antulay has been consistently misquoted. He has all along AGREED that the terrorists killed Mr Karkare.
He has asked for those circumstances to be probed on account of which Mr Karkare became a vulnerable target. Mr Karkare has done the ultimate sacrifice. However, it is not OK on the part of those who gave him orders if it has happened although it could have been avoided.
@ RAM,
You think only mumbai terror attacks will became of hindu vs muslim issue ? what about past attacks ?
People of India have to proud on Antulay about his remarks made in Parliament, he dared to raised the issue in parliament, while he was a minister and his party was in power, he neither fear government nor opposition, he has bring the truth in public, moreover he has given the answer to the people who question the loyality of muslims towards nation !
You said about his calculation the more BJP target him the more he became hero, so you are treating BJP a vilan in Indian Parliament ?
To All People :
Antuly comments was irresposible and given great amount to pak media to bash India.
he has just taken advantage of Vote bank politics.
But i observed in my community there are lot of people is thinking like that,
The only one reason i see this kind of thinking is only because of Untrust towards the Goverment,police.
That need to be re-biuld by Govt and police.
If that happen between this I think we can defeat this terrorism very very easily.
There is absolutely no harm in conducting investigation for the killing of our brave and martyred police officer Hemant Karkare and other police officers which is in the interest of our country, conducting an investigation is in no way pointing out fingers to any one but it is necessary to regain the confidence of our police force and the writer has rightly pointed out the same. We love our country and we should be proud about that even these days the likes of Hemant karkare and Unnikrishnan do prevail in our forces.
now that Antuly has changed his voice and tone (at the instance of Soniaji?). where does congress and antuly stand. the statement was preplanned and intentional
@ Sarfaraz,
On one side you said about vote bank politics and on the other hand you are talking about your community, therefore all people now understand that from which community you belongs!
If Antulay’s comments was irresponsible than the whole opposition and government is irresponsible in dealing with terror in India.
When ever terror strikes in India, government and opposition started blaming to any terror outfit, without even primary investigation, and started arresting the muslims youth around that area on suspision, when Hement Karkare found the actual hindu link behind those terror attacks in India, instead of Government and opposition taking the responsibility of not protecting the lives of Hement Karkare and people killed in all those attacks, and are trying the find the way for scape goat.
“I think People who are against Antulay inquiry demand are against defeating terrorism in India!”
I am against people like Antulay. In democracy you can ask questions, but in democracy you have responsibility of asking right questions , not the childish conspiracy theories, which in a time of national tragedy turns the whole debate into a free for all farce.
I heard of Antulay for first time in my life and he has self proclaimed himself as a hero for merely a conjecture and because he was mobbed by admirers while praying in a mosque. WoW. What has he done for this country of perhaps for so called minorities, can anybody shed some light on it!! Why the hell do we even need a minority minister!! People like him, from any community are detestable and so are those who support them.
People like Antulay are bloat on democracy anyway. Problem is that there are many mane like him in this country who think that democracy is merely about conjecturing and childlike fantasies.
One thing is clear from the frenzy of people who use the ‘Fundamentalist’bogey (Rajdeep Sardesai of CNN iBN) that be you a President, PM or Cabinet Minister, if you are a Muslim, the MOBOCRAZY tries to shout you down. Who were the people blaming Mr Karkare for conducting the arrests in Malegaon blasts. Nobody bothered to raise their voices which includes the ‘alpolo-secularists like Sarfaraz. Miyaan, if you carry a name like ‘Sarfaraz’ and may be you wine and dine in choicest whiskies and pork, the tag will be always of ‘you Muslim’. So instead of proving yourslef India this way, you can continue to offer namaz and be a TRUE muslim so that you are not becoming a terrorist like Amir Ajmal Qasaab, drinking alcohol and asking for pizza. A true Jehadi will not kill a person, not even an opponent of one wants to negotiate, set side an innocent person and ask for food on gun point. Please do not add your bit to the defamation bandwagon. Even if Muslim State Actors act like what USA and Israel does in their field of action, you would be blamed for that as well. Wasnt the dispensation at Makkah and Madinah a ‘State’, still there are fools who apply this modern ‘standards’ to that medieval time. You must be aware that ‘Munafiqeen’ and ‘Kafireen’ think this way only. Let me clear the things here that if a Hindu lives on the ‘Vedas’, in a scholarly opinion, one cannot be called a ‘Kafir’. Unfortunately, majority of Hindus are not living this way. People need to do more than but being apologetic. If the Commissioner of Bombay failed in his duty to guide the ATS (in field operations), he should be taken to task. Nobody should try to shield him just because his name sounds to be Muslim. So stands good for the DGP as well and the Maharashtra govt.
PS: If a candidated seeks votes visiting localities of his constituency, a Muslim candidate need not visit a muslim locality lest he is branded pampersing to vote bank, conversly, a fanatic of the class of a Shiv Sena or BJP, continues to be ‘Nationalist’, may be he instigates Muslims to be killed on the flimsiest of pretext. If this ‘Nationalism’ continues, take it, India goes to ‘DOGS’ earlier.
Time and again, people are misquoting Antulay and creating a furore.
The three officers who were martyred were very key persons, and their being pushed into a situation where they could be killed so easily definitely needs investigation.
Not conducting an enquiry would trivialize their martyrdom. There should be an enquiry.
@undercover indian,
Well, you are talking about responsibilties in Democracy, are these responsibilities you are talking about ?
Until Hemant Karkare investigation result, hindutva media and political parties were doubting on muslims, even they were told unless local muslims support, terror attacks were impossible in India, based on that theory, after every incidents without primary investigation blame any terror outfit, arrested local muslims youth based on suspision, without any proof, harrased the muslims, even some of them charges with TADA and POTA. Moreover you want to see the example of responsibilities in democracy take the example of Gujarat !
Moreover you said what he has done for this country, atleast he has not demolished the mosque, even after taking the oath with high court, atleast he dare to bring the truth in front of the world.
As far as Pakistan is concerned they got the lesson in 1971, when Indira was PM, they didn’t dare to look at India again, people like you and hindutva forces are making pakistan a hero, by linking every incident to Pakistan, in order washing hand with their responsibilites.
It will be quite proper to add a tailpiece to the much adoed controversy on Antulay’s remarks about the killing of Karkare and senior police personnel of Maharashtra.The BJP,Siva Sena Nad their allies stalled the Parliament for days and Antulay was gralanded with many attributes ,including ‘anti-national!’ On the 18th December, in a TV channel interview, BJP’s Leader of Opposition in Rajya Sabha, Jaswant Singh,hs asserted that releasing of noted terrorists from Tihar jail and taking them to Kandhar and swapping them for highjacked plane passengers, “Was the right decision!”andI will do the same thing, if such situation arises in future!”Neena Vyas in “A Tale of Two Statements”(The HIndu dated 25/12/2008 -OP-ED page)concludes that:”What Mr. Antulay said may have been ridiculous -but what Mr. Singh said is disastrous for a nation that has taken the pledge to fight terrorism to its death!”Has not this weakened India’s case?Is it not like an open invitation to potential hijackers and hostage takers?asks Neena. Why this double standard?
Nyayman, you can read this about Kandahar by Kanchan Gupta and make up your own mind:
http://www.dailypioneer.com/145600/The-truth-behind-Kandahar.html
@ Amit,
Nice story written by Gupta, After NDA came to power terrorism were on the rise, even after the incident no one from the cabinet were sacked, now people like Gupta coming into public rescuing the cowardly decision made by PMO for releasing the terrorists, moreover people like you appreciating the act……..
Mr.Amit, I went through Kanchan Gupta’s write up on “Truth behind Kandhar”.I am sorry to say that like many,I too could not get at the truth! The Two vital questions connected with “Kandhar Episode” are:(1) Did the Ministerial colleagues,including Dy.PM. and Home Minister, Advani knew that Foreign Minister Jaswant Singh would travel to Kandhar with released Terrorists? and (2) More important, was the PM aware of it? Gupta’s reply is very elusive! She says:”The answer is both Yes and NO!”
What do you make of it? One blogger has made it very clear that The Foreign Minister’s immediate presence was necessitated by US’ insistence that a Swiss banker, who had the original currency blocks of world’s many countries and who knew all currency secrets, should be saved and let off at any cost. So Jaswant Singh did not go to keep up his promise to the relatives of hostages as Gupta claims.
Nyayman
Since you believe so much in your theory
1. Why should a Swiss Banker be carrying the currency blocks of many countries from Kathmandu to New Delhi?
2. And what unique secrets could he have possibly have that he needed to be escorted back?
Did you even consider the possibility that Masood Azhar is actually a RSS man in disguise who needed to be delivered to the allies of Bajrang Dal based in Kandahar?
The decision to release the terroists were taken after the botched up attempt to stop the plane in Amritsar. Govt. took the decision that it felt was best at that time. There were many mistakes made and important part is that more than 300 people were saved. For the future we can choose to be better prepared. Please note from the article about the prevailing sentiment in India at that time.